It could be a first timer. My birds are Easter birds and in a span of a few weeks we found 4 or 5 of them.garyb said:My hens have been laying since July 29, I have two bantams and five reds. I have one Rhode Island Red that I think is a hen but does everything the roosters do except crow.. Today i got my five brown eggs and one bantam egg. That is to big for a bantam. Could this be that other hens first egg?